“The global economic landscape is shifting, driven by the rise of new powers and alternative financial institutions. While BRICS may challenge the status quo, the IMF and World Bank still have a vital role in ensuring global stability.”
Overview: IMF and World Bank Collaboration
The global institutions such as International Monetary Fund and World Bank work closely together in assessing economic situations of countries, managing country’s debt burdens, helping countries adapt and build resilience to climate changes, and collaborating on policy reforms and investments in countries. The two institutions leverage their respective expertise and resources to assist member countries in addressing economic challenges and highlight their relevance in a shifting world economy.
The IMF and World Bank have had mixed bag of results in their efforts to promote economic stability and development globally. Some of their notable successes include – providing emergency funding during crises like 1980’s debt crisis, Asian financial crisis, global financial crisis, and Covid 19 pandemic to overcome balance of payment difficulties, and debt relief initiatives that have reduced debt burdens for heavily indebted nations.
However, the institutions have also faced failures – providing inadequate stabilization programs, infrastructure projects that supported white elephants with costs exceeding benefits, lack of transparency and failures to deliver promises of economic development after decades of World Bank lending. For instance, rapid implementation of policy recommendations and stringent loan conditions of these institutions, their new liberal policies without adequate social safety nets contributed to crises in Africa in 1980-1990, Mozambique’s hidden debt crises in 2016, Argentina’s economic crises in 1999-2002, Greece debt crises in 2010, Nicaragua’s structural mis-adjustments in 1990’s, Indonesia environmental and social impact, Ethiopia’s increased food insecurity through agricultural reforms, and Honduras mining project that contaminated water resources and loss of agricultural land.
Criticism for Western dominance on Institutions
Global financial institutions like the IMF and World Bank have long been pillars of the international economic system, offering financial assistance, policy advice, and development support across the globe. With decades of expertise and deep financial resources, they hold substantial influence over economic reforms and development strategies. However, these institutions are increasingly viewed as tools of Western dominance, with criticisms targeting their stringent loan conditions, fiscal austerity measures, and slow adaptation to evolving global dynamics. The disparity in economic aid where developed countries prioritise their own geopolitical interests over the developing needs of the poor nations perpetuates a sense of mistrust.
A significant challenge to their authority comes from emerging institutions like the BRICS-led New Development Bank (NDB) and the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB). These alternatives, backed by emerging economies such as China and India, provide development financing with fewer political conditions, appealing to nations wary of traditional Western oversight.
Lending Capacities (2023):
- IMF: $1 trillion
- World Bank: $70 billion
- BRICS NDB: $32 billion committed since 2015
BRICS: Redefining Global Governance
- Alternative Financial Institutions: The NDB and the Contingent Reserve Arrangement (CRA) offer emerging economies access to infrastructure funding and liquidity support without the conditionality’s typical of IMF or World Bank programs.
- Advocating Multi polarity: BRICS members emphasize the need for a diverse global governance structure that reflects the priorities of the Global South, promoting strategic autonomy free from Western influence.
- Reforming Governance: BRICS advocates for a more inclusive global financial architecture, pushing for changes in decision-making processes within the IMF and World Bank to better represent the interests of developing nations.
- Reducing Dollar Dependence: BRICS countries are increasingly trading in local currencies and exploring alternatives to the US dollar, signaling a shift toward a more decentralized global monetary system.
- Expanding Influence: The recent expansion of BRICS to include more countries strengthens its collective voice and creates a broader coalition aimed at reshaping global economic governance.
The BRICS countries overtook the G7 countries share of the world’s total gross domestic product (GDP) in terms of purchasing power parity (PPP) in 2018. By 2024, the difference had increased even further, the BRICS now holding a total 35 percent of the world’s GDP compared to 30 percent held by the G7 countries.
Global Reserve Currencies (2023):
- US Dollar: 58%
- Euro: 20%
- British Pound: 5%
- Yen: 6%
- Other Currencies: 8%
Road Ahead : IMF and World Bank
As BRICS strengthens its position, the IMF and World Bank face a critical juncture. To remain relevant, these institutions must evolve and embrace greater inclusivity. They can enhance their collaboration with BRICS nations by offering financial support during crises, providing tailored policy advice, and conducting debt sustainability analyses aligned with local development goals.
Moreover, these institutions can contribute to the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) by funding poverty reduction, education, and climate initiatives in BRICS countries. Partnerships focused on these areas can bridge the gap between the traditional global order and emerging economic powers.
Collaboration over Competition
Rather than seeing BRICS as a threat, the IMF and World Bank can explore synergies with these new institutions. Joint efforts to mobilize resources and create sustainable lending frameworks could foster a more resilient global financial system. By increasing transparency, enhancing representation of emerging economies, and responding proactively to new challenges, these institutions can maintain their influence in a multipolar world.
Conclusion
The global economic landscape is shifting, driven by the rise of new powers and alternative financial institutions. While BRICS may challenge the status quo, the IMF and World Bank still have a vital role in ensuring global stability. Their ability to adapt, collaborate, and offer value-driven partnerships will determine their relevance in this evolving world order.
Sources – IMF official Data, World Bank July 2024 updates.
Read more: https://wordbulls.in/blog/
